Breathe music....

No DJ,No loud speakers, No tipping to tapping, No records, No LIVE performance, No followers,
its just being one who breathes MUSIC...rhythm..everything has rhythm..everything dances.....!!!
Insanity,bravado,rebellion...but yet SIMPLE.....saying hello to all Music_Freaks here...
Stay at Marine driving city..Mumbai..
Looking forward for more Connections..

Welcome to the forum! Glad to have you here.

thanks............

You do realize that melody plays a far greater role in defining music than the rhythm ...

Originally Posted by alpha1

You do realize that melody plays a far greater role in defining music than the rhythm ...

he seems more of the dancer type so maybe that's why very rhythm focused

....everything dances.....!!!

*rolls eyes*


welcome to the forum anyway have fun

Originally Posted by alpha1

You do realize that melody plays a far greater role in defining music than the rhythm ...

I would disagree with this. I don't think there can be an argument to back either of us up here though. It's just something you think you know.

Of course, that doesn't mean I don't think the original poster doesn't have a point.

Well just to illustrate my point:

You take a song.
And change the rhythm structure.
You can still recognize it.

You take a song.
And change the notes played in it.
Can you recognize it?

Originally Posted by alpha1

You take a song.
And change the rhythm structure.
You can still recognize it.

I disagree...what I think you're doing in your head is changing the rhythm a little and the melody completely. To start with, I don't think separating the two is a great idea. Anyway, I'd post a tune if I was good enough to...since I'm not, I'll use this link to illustrate my point.

The Easter Egg In Hans Zimmer’s ‘Inception’ Score | Geeks of Doom

To be honest, I found this amazing....and I really couldn't have been able to tell even if I'd been familiar with the original score.

i really dont understand why people think melody is superior to rhythm...god give them brains...

Originally Posted by Sumanovo razor

i really dont understand why people think melody is superior to rhythm...god give them brains...

would you care to explain why you think otherwise because i'm sure you can't explain it and sound older than 13 at the same time. you should seriously learn some manners for behaving on a public forum before posting something like this next time

**sarcasm** anyways m sorry sir...and yes its not always that melody rules ...and if you want to know why then i may publish a video on this topic explaining why...not now maybe later... .

I personally dont believe in this, but yes there are people who do. I'd rather not get into the rhythm vs. melody debate but i'd like to say for me the live performance, the interaction with audience is all a big part of the experience for me. Playing what i like is fine by me but i like the challenge of creating something that others will like. But then again my goals and reasons for playing music are different.

Originally Posted by ayu135

I personally dont believe in this, but yes there are people who do. I'd rather not get into the rhythm vs. melody debate but i'd like to say for me the live performance, the interaction with audience is all a big part of the experience for me. Playing what i like is fine by me but i like the challenge of creating something that others will like. But then again my goals and reasons for playing music are different.

actually what a lot of people like depends on how they approach the music and hence, the challenge you speak of is rather a marketing challenge than a musical one. a musical challenge would be to create an objectively good piece of music that in an ideal world everyone would appreciate, if not like.

Originally Posted by bjr

I disagree...what I think you're doing in your head is changing the rhythm a little and the melody completely. To start with, I don't think separating the two is a great idea. Anyway, I'd post a tune if I was good enough to...since I'm not, I'll use this link to illustrate my point.

The Easter Egg In Hans Zimmer’s ‘Inception’ Score | Geeks of Doom

To be honest, I found this amazing....and I really couldn't have been able to tell even if I'd been familiar with the original score.

Not really.
All I said was to keep the melody notes, and change the rhythm in whichever way possible.
Compared to: keep the rhythm and change the notes in whichever way possible.
Try this on someone who is not musically inclined.

And yes separating the two is not a great idea because both in unison make a good sounding music.
I cannot have good bhangra music on a waltz rhythm.

Unfortunately cannot access the video now, but when they talk about slowing the original three times, are they talking about only changing the speed/tempo or they are talking about changing the notes also (1/3rd freq of the original)?

Originally Posted by Sumanovo razor

i really dont understand why people think melody is superior to rhythm...god give them brains...

I really don't understand why ppl think that melody is not superior to rhythm ... god give them brains ... ( = to present an argument, and try provide points in favour or against)